This article is stated as at 21 November 2026. The HMRC verification problem reported on Xero's status page was still open on that date and may since have been fixed, and the notification dates shown are our calculation from the regulations rather than dates HMRC publishes. Take advice on your own circumstances before acting.
CIS nil returns are back, eleven years after HMRC decided it could manage without them. Since 6 April 2026, a mainstream contractor who has paid subcontractors before, but pays none in a tax month, must either file a CIS nil return by the 19th of the following month or tell HMRC at least 14 days before that tax month starts that no payments will be made. Do neither and HMRC charges a late filing penalty of £100, rising the longer the return is outstanding. The next deadline is 19 December 2026, for the tax month 6 November to 5 December 2026.
What changed on 6 April 2026?
From 2015 until April 2026, a contractor who paid no subcontractors in a month could stay quiet. The Income Tax (Construction Industry Scheme) (Amendment) Regulations 2026 came into force on 6 April 2026 and add a new regulation 4(9A): a mainstream contractor “who has previously made contract payments” but made none in a tax month must make a return “indicating that no such payments were made, not later than 14 days after the end of the relevant tax month.”
The change was first announced at Budget 2025. HMRC says dropping nil returns in 2015 “did not reduce administrative burdens for contractors, or for HMRC, and resulted in erroneous late filing penalties.”
Many pages still ranking say nil returns are optional, which has been wrong since 6 April 2026, so update any month end checklist built on that advice. If you never stopped filing nil returns, HMRC says nothing changes for you.
Who has to file a CIS nil return?
The duty sits with mainstream contractors (builders, trades firms, developers and similar businesses) who have paid subcontractors under the scheme before. If that’s you, every tax month with no subcontractor payments needs either a nil return or an advance notice to HMRC.
Deemed contractors are treated differently. These are businesses and public bodies outside construction that spend heavily on it, for example over £3 million, and HMRC’s CIS 340 guide says they “are not legally required to file a nil return”. If a deemed contractor tells HMRC nothing, a penalty is still issued, though HMRC cancels it once the business confirms it paid no subcontractors that month. We’d file the nil return anyway, because it takes less time than getting a penalty cancelled.
Since 6 April 2026, payments to subcontractors that are local authorities or public bodies also fall outside CIS altogether, so don’t verify them, don’t make deductions, and leave those payments off your monthly return.
The CIS nil return deadline and late filing penalties
CIS runs on tax months, from the 6th of one month to the 5th of the next, and each monthly return must reach HMRC by the 19th, 14 days after the tax month ends. A nil return follows the same timetable: the return for 6 May to 5 June is due by 19 June, and the one for 6 November to 5 December 2026 is due by 19 December 2026.
Miss it and the CIS late filing penalties set out on GOV.UK apply to a nil return just as they do to a return full of payments.
| How late the return is (UK-wide, 2026/27) | Penalty |
|---|---|
| 1 day | £100 |
| 2 months | £200 |
| 6 months | £300 or 5% of the CIS deductions on the return, whichever is higher |
| 12 months | £300 or 5% of the CIS deductions on the return, whichever is higher |
| Later than 12 months | A possible additional penalty of up to £3,000 or 100% of the CIS deductions on the return, whichever is higher |
A nil return has no deductions, so 5% of them is nothing and the £300 figure is the one that applies at six and twelve months. The cost builds quickly across quiet months: each missed month carries its own £100 penalty from the day after its 19th deadline, so a contractor who files nothing for three quiet tax months over the summer faces at least three £100 penalties, £300 in total, and the earliest of them reaches the two month stage just as the third falls due.
If the return due on 19 November 2026 slipped through, file it now. Appeals against a penalty must be made within 30 days of the date on the notice. If quiet months keep slipping through, our Xero bookkeeping services can run the CIS routine for you.
Nil return or inactivity request: which should you use?
A nil return is filed after the event, by the 19th, once you know for certain nothing was paid. It suits contractors whose work is lumpy, where a quiet month is rarely planned, and it takes a few minutes in your software.
An inactivity request is made in advance. Under the new regulation 4(9B), the nil return duty falls away for a tax month if you tell HMRC you’ll make no payments and “the notification is made not later than 14 days before the start of the tax month.” HMRC can then treat your scheme as inactive for up to 6 months, which suits a planned pause, such as a developer between sites.
- To cover the tax month starting 6 December 2026, notice has to reach HMRC by Sunday 22 November 2026, so use the online service or your software. For the tax month starting 6 January 2027, the last day is 23 December 2026. Miss the deadline and a nil return for that month is due by the 19th of the following month, for example 19 January 2027 for 6 December 2026 to 5 January 2027.
- If you pay a subcontractor during an inactive period, file a normal return for that month. That closes the inactivity, though you can set a new inactive period of up to 6 months by ticking a box on that return.
- Six months is the ceiling, so diary the end date and restart monthly filing on time.
Give notice through HMRC’s CIS online service or your software, as CIS 340 says, so you have a record of what you told HMRC and when.
Filing the monthly CIS return from Xero
Xero lets contractors “verify your subcontractors, automate their deductions, and file your monthly CIS returns directly with HMRC”. When you enter a subcontractor’s bill, Xero works out the deduction at 20%, 30% or 0% for gross payment status, and it can email payment and deduction statements to subcontractors in bulk. For quiet months, Xero’s guidance says that if you don’t pay any subcontractors, you should send a nil return from Xero or tell HMRC by phone.
Check two things before you rely on it. CIS for contractors is only available on some Xero plans, and verification, filing and bulk statements carry an extra monthly cost on top of the plan, so confirm what your subscription includes on Xero’s pricing page. And follow the current Xero Central article for the exact steps, because Xero updates its screens.
Each month end, work through these steps:
- Soon after the 5th, reconcile the bank account so every payment made in the tax month is in Xero. An unreconciled subcontractor payment is easy to miss, and a nil return for a month when you did pay someone is a wrong return.
- If there were payments, check each subcontractor’s deduction rate before you file. If there were none, send the nil return from Xero there and then.
- File each month through one channel only, because CIS 340 warns that using HMRC’s CIS online service and commercial software at the same time “may cause returns to be overwritten”.
- Pay any deductions separately: by the 22nd electronically, or the 19th by post. If your average monthly payments to HMRC are below £1,500 you may pay quarterly, but the returns stay monthly.
If you’re VAT registered, keep the CIS return and the VAT return as separate jobs in the diary with their own deadlines; our guide to filing a VAT return in Xero covers the VAT side. CIS also runs apart from PAYE for your own employees, which our Xero payroll page explains.
Verifying subcontractors while HMRC’s service is failing
Before you pay a new subcontractor, you must verify them with HMRC. The same applies to a subcontractor you’ve used before if they haven’t appeared on one of your CIS returns in the current or last 2 tax years, and GOV.UK’s verification guidance says that if you need to verify more than 50 you’ll need commercial CIS software.
Since 12 November 2026, Xero’s status page has reported errors when users try to verify subcontractors (the incident title says “contractors”, but it is subcontractor verification that fails). Xero says HMRC has confirmed known issues with its CIS verification service, and its update of 19 November 2026 says HMRC is continuing to investigate. It was still open on 21 November 2026, so check the status page for the latest position.
Xero’s workaround is to verify by signing in to HMRC’s CIS online service, or, if you can’t use the online service, to call the CIS Helpline on 0300 200 3210, which is limited to verifying up to 10 subcontractors per call. Don’t pay a new subcontractor and plan to verify later. Verify through HMRC directly, note the deduction rate HMRC confirms, and check the rate held in Xero matches before you approve their bill. Verifying on HMRC’s site doesn’t change where you file, so keep sending the monthly return from Xero.
The outage doesn’t affect nil returns: a month with no payments involves no verification, so there’s no reason to miss the 19th.
Key dates
| Date | What happens (UK-wide, tax year 2026/27) |
|---|---|
| 6 April 2026 | Nil return duty reinstated for mainstream contractors |
| 22 November 2026 (Sunday) | Last day to tell HMRC you’ll make no payments in the tax month starting 6 December 2026 (our calculation from regulation 4(9B)) |
| 19 December 2026 (Saturday) | Return, including any nil return, due for 6 November to 5 December 2026 |
| 22 December 2026 | Electronic payment of deductions due for 6 November to 5 December 2026 (19 December if paying by post) |
| 23 December 2026 | Last day to tell HMRC you’ll make no payments in the tax month starting 6 January 2027 (our calculation) |
| 19 January 2027 | Return due for 6 December 2026 to 5 January 2027 |
GOV.UK doesn’t say the deadline moves when the 19th falls on a weekend, so treat Friday 18 December 2026 as the real deadline for the December return.
Questions Xero users ask
I've registered as a contractor but never paid a subcontractor. Do I need to file nil returns?
The new rule applies to mainstream contractors who have previously made contract payments, which suggests a newly registered contractor with no payments yet has no nil return duty. That reading comes from the wording of the regulations, and GOV.UK guidance does not say so directly. If HMRC is expecting returns from you, filing a nil return or making an inactivity request is quicker than disputing a penalty later.
Can I file a CIS nil return over the phone?
HMRC's internal manual says nil returns by telephone can only be accepted at the CIS Contact Centre on 0300 200 3210, and Xero's guidance also mentions telling HMRC by phone. HMRC's main CIS guide points contractors to the CIS online service or commercial software instead. We prefer filing online or from Xero, because you keep a record of what was sent and when.
How do I file a CIS nil return in Xero?
Xero's guidance says that if you don't pay any subcontractors in a month, you should send a nil return from Xero. Reconcile the bank account first to confirm nothing was paid between the 6th and the 5th, then file the return from Xero by the 19th, following the current Xero Central steps. Check your plan includes CIS for contractors, and don't file the same month through HMRC's online service as well.
I've had a CIS penalty for a month when I paid nobody. What can I do?
File the missing nil return straight away so it doesn't reach the next penalty stage, then appeal within 30 days of the date on the penalty notice. You can appeal through HMRC's online service or in writing, quoting your UTR and the payment reference, but not by phone. HMRC says a penalty is due only where there is no reasonable excuse, so explain clearly why the return was missed.
Speak to us. To talk through your Xero setup or a move to Xero, contact JacRox or call us on 0161 832 4451.
Sources
- The Income Tax (Construction Industry Scheme) (Amendment) Regulations 2026 (SI 2026/289), as made
- SI 2026/289 regulation 2 (nil return, reg 4(9A) and (9B))
- Simplification and administrative improvements to the Construction Industry Scheme
- Construction Industry Scheme: a guide for contractors and subcontractors (CIS 340)
- What you must do as a CIS contractor: File your monthly returns
- What you must do as a CIS contractor: Pay deductions to HMRC
- What you must do as a CIS contractor: Verify subcontractors
- CISR61280 – Nil returns: overview
- CISR63660 – How to log and capture a nil return by telephone
- File Your CIS Returns Online with Xero UK
- UK: CIS – Error when verifying CIS contractors